Freedom and obligatory performance of a contract in the civil law of Ukraine
Abstract
An analysis of the legislation of Ukraine, as well as doctrinal approaches and judicial practice regarding the understanding of freedom and obligation to perform a contract in the civil law of Ukraine, has been carried out. It has been concluded that the legislation in many respects creates situation where the principle of freedom of contract is restricted. At the same time, neither legislation nor law-enforcement practice contain any reservations that would allow changing the relevant state of affairs in favor of the principles of dispositive regulation of private law relations.
It has been noted that the principle of freedom of contract within civil law relations does not have an absolute nature, which is confirmed by the provisions of civil legislation that ensure the procedure for conclusion, execution and responsibility for individual contractual structures regulated by the Civil Code of Ukraine (e.g., a public contract, an accession agreement, etc.), as well as relations connected with consumer protection.
Based on the conducted research, it has been proposed to single out two main models for restriction of contract freedom: 1) establishment of direct restrictions by the state, by indicating which specific conditions the parties are forbidden to agree on in the contract; 2) consolidation of general evaluation standards that the transaction and its terms must meet by the legislator or higher courts at the level of law or law enforcement practice.
Attention has been focused on the fact that the ability to realize interests under one’s own responsibility is the basis of the contract, and that contractual binding and responsibility are its inevitable consequences. Despite the fact that the legislation provides for the obligation to perform the contract (Article 629 of the Civil Code of Ukraine), it also provides for cases of contract parties’ release from the performance of their obligations (from the obligation of the contract).
Downloads
References
Fuller Lon L., 1999. Anatomy of law [Anatomiia prava]. Kyiv: Sfera. (Transl.: Komarov N.).
Karapetov A.G., 2009. Freedom of contract and the limits of the imperativeness of civil law norms [Svoboda dogovora i predely imperativnosti norm grazhdanskogo prava]. Vestnik Vysšego Arbitražnogo Suda Rossijskoj Federacii, No. 11, pp. 100-133.
Drishliuk V.I., 2016. The principle of freedom of contract in contractual relations in the field of providing medical services [Pryntsyp svobody dohovoru v dohovirnykh vidnosynakh u sferi nadannia medychnykh posluh]. Pìvdennoukraïnsʹkij pravničij časopis – South Ukrainian Law Journal, No. 3-4, pp. 67-69.
Bodnar T.V., Dzera O.V., Kuznietsova N.S. et al., 2008. Contract law of Ukraine. General part [Dohovirne pravo Ukrainy. Zahalna chastyna]. Kyiv: Yurinkom Inter. (Ed.: Dzera O.V.).
Spasybo-Fatieieva I.V. (Ed.), 2010. The Civil Code of Ukraine. Scientific and practical commentary (explanations, interpretations, recommendations using the positions of higher courts, the Ministry of Justice, scientists, specialists) [Tsyvilnyi kodeks Ukrainy. Naukovo-praktychnyi komentar (poiasnennia, tlumachennia, rekomendatsii z vykorystanniam pozytsii vyshchykh sudovykh instantsii, Ministerstva yustytsii, naukovtsiv, fakhivtsiv)]: in 12 vols. Vol. 1. Kharkiv: FOP Kolisnyk A. A.
Spasybo-Fatieieva I.V. (Ed.), 2012. The Civil Code of Ukraine. Scientific and practical commentary (explanations, interpretations, recommendations using the positions of higher courts, the Ministry of Justice, scientists, specialists) [Tsyvilnyi kodeks Ukrainy. Naukovo-praktychnyi komentar (poiasnennia, tlumachennia, rekomendatsii z vykorystanniam pozytsii vyshchykh sudovykh instantsii, Ministerstva yustytsii, naukovtsiv, fakhivtsiv)]: in 12 vols. Vol. 7. Kharkiv: FOP Lysiak L.
Kuznietsova N., 2003. Principles of modern obligation law of Ukraine [Pryntsypy suchasnoho zoboviazalnoho prava Ukrainy]. Ukrainske pravo, No. 4, pp. 9-15.
Merezhko A.A., 2002. Lex mercatoria: theory and principles of transnational trade law [Lex mercatoria: teoriya i printsipy transnatsional’nogo torgovogo prava]. Kiev: Takson.
Maidanyk R.A., 2002. Problems of trust relations in civil law [Problemy dovirchykh vidnosyn v tsyvilnomu pravi]. Kyiv: VPTs “Kyivskyi universytet”.
Luts A.V., 2001. Freedom of contract in the civil law of Ukraine [Svoboda dohovoru v tsyvilnomu pravi Ukrainy]. Abstract of Ph.D. dissertation. Taras Shevchenko Kyiv National University.
Karapetov A.G. and Savalev A.I., 2012. Freedom of contract and its limits [Svoboda dogovora i ee predely]: in 2 vols. Vol. 1. Moscow: Statut.
Alekseev S.S., 2010. Collected works [Sobranie sochinenii]: in 10 vols. Vol. 6. Moscow: Statut.
Hetman A.P., Borysova V.I., Yevsieiev O.P. et al., 2012. The contract as a universal legal structure [Dohovir yak universalna pravova konstruktsiia]. Kharkiv: Pravo. (Eds: Hetman A.P. and Borysova V.I.).
Copyright (c) 2022 Yu. M. Zhornokui
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
