Directions for improving the legal regulation of forensic DNA analysis in Ukraine in the context of integration into the European Union
Abstract
An analysis of European standards and main trends in the field of legal regulation of forensic DNA analysis has been carried out. It has been established that the general European legislation defines recommendations on the general principles of using DNA analysis within the framework of the criminal justice system, establishes the obligation of each state to create and maintain a national DNA database, exchange information based on DNA databases, take measures to protect personal data, store DNA profiles of persons convicted of sexual offenses against children, to accredit forensic laboratories to ensure the proper quality of molecular genetic research. Taking into account the experience of European countries, it can be seen that a comprehensive approach to the improvement of domestic legislation, namely the implementation of the law on the national DNA database, the introduction of amendments and additions to the current Code of Criminal Procedure of Ukraine, other laws and departmental regulations regarding the use of DNA analysis in criminal proceedings, is a necessary prerequisite for bringing this area of law enforcement to a new qualitative level.
Together with the adoption of the Law of Ukraine “On the State Registration of Human Genomic Information”, it is necessary to introduce changes and additions to the Code of Criminal Procedure of Ukraine in order to harmonize the provisions of these normative legal acts, which primarily concern the improvement of the procedure for obtaining samples for molecular genetic research. It has been substantiated that the experience of Germany and the Netherlands regarding the legal regulation of mass DNA testing at the stage of pre-trial investigation of serious and especially serious crimes can be useful for Ukraine. Taking into account the rapid development of forensic DNA analysis technologies and the introduction of the latest methods, which are characterized by a much greater degree of interference in the personal and family life of a person, compared to traditional methods of STR profiling, there is a need for a legislative definition of the permissible limits of forensic DNA research within the framework of criminal proceedings in Ukraine.
Downloads
References
Toom V., 2012. Bodies of science and law: Forensic DNA profiling, biological bodies, and biopower. Journal of Law and Society, Vol. 39, Iss. 1, pp. 150-166. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6478.2012.00575.x.
Stepaniuk R., Kikinchuk V., Pyrih I., Pletenets V. and Prylovskyi V., 2022. Multifaceted approach to legislative regulation for using DNA analysis in criminal proceedings of Ukraine. Amazonia Investiga, Vol. 11, Iss. 50, pp. 130-139. https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2022.50.02.13.
Drachuk S.M. and Khlan V.H., 2016. International and national experience of using DNA research in forensic and kriminalistik practice: a comparative legal analysis [Mizhnarodnyi ta natsionalnyi dosvid vykorystannia DNK doslidzhen v sudovo-ekspertnii ta kryminalistychnii praktytsi: porivnialno-pravovyi analiz]. Kriminalistika i sudebnaâ èkspertiza – Criminalistics and Forensics, Iss. 61, pp. 541-549.
Kultenko O.V., 2014. On the need for legislative approval of the concept of molecular genetic examination in Ukraine [Pro neobkhidnist zakonodavchoho skhvalennia kontseptsii provedennia molekuliarno-henetychnoi ekspertyzy v Ukraini]. Deržava ì pravo – State and Law, Iss. 66, pp. 246-254.
Bilous V.V., 2015. On the introduction of state genomic registration in Ukraine [Pro vprovadzhennia derzhavnoi henomnoi reiestratsii v Ukraini]. Naukovij vìsnik Hersonsʹkogo deržavnogo unìversitetu. Serìâ Ûridičnì nauki – Scientific Herald of Kherson State University, Iss. 4, pp. 89-95.
Bilous V.V., 2015. Legislative provision of genetic identification in Ukraine: problems of the theory and practice of forensics [Zakonodavche zabezpechennia henetychnoi identyfikatsii v Ukraini: problemy teorii i praktyky kryminalistyky]. Pravo ì suspìlʹstvo – Law and Society, Iss. 2, pp. 216-224.
Drozd V., Rusnak I., Olishevskyi O., Hapotii V. and Minkova O., 2019. Obtaining samples for examination in criminal proceedings: problems of normative regulation and law enforcement. Georgian Medical News. No. 292, pp. 129-134.
Leiba O.A., 2021. Selection of biological samples for expert research: controversial issues of regulatory regulation and law enforcement practice [Vidibrannia biolohichnykh zrazkiv dlia ekspertnoho doslidzhennia: spirni pytannia normatyvnoi rehlamentatsii ta praktyky pravozastosuvannia]. Naukovij vìsnik Užgorodsʹkogo nacìonalʹnogo unìversitetu. Serìâ Pravo – Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law, Iss. 65, pp. 308-313.
Horelkina K., 2021. Observance of human rights and freedoms during forced collection of biological samples [Dotrymannia prav i svobod liudyny pry prymusovomu vidbyranni biolohichnykh zrazkiv]. Bulletin of the Penitentiary association of Ukraine, Iss. 1, pp. 133-140. https://doi.org/10.34015/2523-4552.2021.1.12.
Horpyniuk O.P., 2019. International standards for the collection and use of biometric data (DNA samples) in the activities of law enforcement agencies [Mizhnarodni standarty nakopychennia ta vykorystannia biometrychnykh danykh (zrazkiv DNK) u diialnosti pravookhoronnykh orhaniv]. Juridical Scientific and Electronic Journal, [online] No. 2, pp. 245-249. Available at http://www.lsej.org.ua/2_2019/70.pdf [Accessed 16 June 2022].
Kaplina O.V., Shylo O. H. and Titko I. A., 2019. Using the samples of human biological materials in the criminal procedure: the practice of the European court of human rights. Wiad Lek. No. 72, pp. 1576-1581.
Husieva V.O., 2021. Prospects for the implementation of foreign experience in the use of DNA records in the practice of Ukraine [Perspektyvy vprovadzhennia zarubizhnoho dosvidu vykorystannia DNK-oblikiv u praktyku Ukrainy]. Naukovij vìsnik Nacìonalʹnoï akademìï vnutrìšnìh sprav – Scientific Herald of the National Academy of Internal Affairs, No. 2, pp. 121-131.
Lynch M., 2003. God’s signature: DNA profiling, the new gold standard in forensic science. Endeavour, Vol. 27, Iss. 2, pp. 93-97. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0160-9327(03)00068-1.
Gill P., 2019. DNA evidence and miscarriages of justice. Forensic Science International. Iss. 294, pp. 31-33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2018.12.003.
Gupta R., Gupta S. and Gupta M., 2016. Journey of DNA Evidence in Legal Arena: An Insight on Its Legal Perspective Worldwide and Highlight on Admissibility in India. Journal of Forensic Sciences and Medicine, Iss. 2, pp. 102-106.
Machado H. and Granja R., 2020. DNA Technologies in Criminal Investigation and Courts. Forensic Genetics in the Governance of Crime. No. 3, pp. 45-56. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15-2429-5_4.
AARli R., 2013. The Status and Meaning of Criminal Procedure: An exploration of the reception of DNA evidence in the criminal process. Bergen Journal of Criminal Law & Criminal Justice, Iss. 1, pp. 63-74.
Soleto M. H. and Fiodorova A., 2014. DNA and law enforcement in the European Union: tools and human rights protection. Utrecht Law Review, Iss. 10, pp. 149-162.
Samuel G. and Prainsack B., 2018. Forensic DNA phenotyping in Europe: views “on the ground” from those who have a professional stake in the technology. New Genetics and Society, Vol. 38, Iss. 2, pp. 119-141. https://doi.org/10.1080/14636778.2018.1549984.
Schneider P. M., Prainsack B. and Kayser M., 2019. The Use of Forensic DNA Phenotyping in Predicting Appearance and Biogeographic Ancestry. Deutsches Ärzteblatt International, Iss. 51-52, pp. 873-880. https://doi.org/10.3238/arztebl.2019.0873.
Vervaele J., de Graaf F. and Tielemans N., 2012. The dutch focus on DNA in the criminal justice system: net-widening of judicial data. Revue Internationale de Droit Pénal, Iss. 83, pp. 459-480. https://doi.org/10.3917/ridp.833.0459.
Copyright (c) 2022 R. L. Stepaniuk, V. V. Kikinchuk
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
