Formal Security in the Works of Legal Scholars of Pre-Soviet Period

E. E.  Silantyeva

doi:10.32631/v.2021.2.04

E. E. Silantyeva Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs

DOI: https://doi.org/10.32631/v.2021.2.04

Keywords: formal security, legal norms, features of law, legislative procedure, authority of the State, legal writing.

Abstract

The article is focused on a retrospective analysis of developments in the field of scientific and theoretical ideas about the formal security in law, suggested by legal scholars in the XIX – early XX centuries. Thus, there was already a clear understanding at that stage that legal norms were designed to accurately record the rights, obligations, certain legal consequences, and the accuracy of legal norms determined their binding nature, the specifics of sanctions, etc. The works of experts in civil studies, encyclopedia and philosophy of law have been analyzed in this way, in particular D. Grimm, N. Gredeskul, J. Pokrovsky, P. Novgorodtsev, L. Petrazhytskyi, N. Korkunov, M. Oleksiiev, Ye. Trubetskyi, G. Shershnevych and others.

Despite the lack of the very concept of “formal security” in the pre-Soviet period, legal scholars have repeatedly studied various aspects of the specified issue, especially in the context of studying the features inherent in legal norms and comparing the mechanism of legal and moral norms. Thus, there was a clear understanding even at that stage that legal norms were designed to accurately record the rights, obligations, certain legal consequences, and the accuracy of legal norms determined their binding nature, the specifics of sanctions, etc.

At the same time, there were often assessments of formal security as a somewhat severe, purely external phenomenon, which implied a restriction of individual freedom and was mandatory. Undoubtedly, this attitude to the role of formal security distorted the mission of law in society and reduced its axiological potential as a mega-regulator of relations: the state – society – the individual. In turn, this explains the limitations and imperfection of the system of Russian imperial justice, unjustifiably widespread use of formal security in practical legal activities, although it was criticized by some scholars of the early XX century, who studied philosophical and legal issues.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

E. E. Silantyeva, Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs

Candidate of Law.
Department of Criminal Procedure, Criminalistics and Expertology.

References

Pankratova V., 2017. Historical origins of the principle of legal certainty [Istorychni vytoky pryntsypu pravovoi vyznachenosti]. Pìdpriêmnictvo, gospodarstvo ì pravo – Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law, No. 1, pp. 187-192.

Bervi-Flerovskii V., 1869. Freedom of speech, tolerance and our press laws [Svoboda rechi, terpimost` i nashi zakony o pechati]. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya Neklyudova.

Grimm D., 1895. Encyclopedia of law: lectures given at the military law academy [Entsiklopediya prava: lektsii, chitannye v Voenno-yuridicheskoi akademii]. St. Petersburg: Parovaya tipo-lit. inzh. I. Gershuna.

Novgorodtsev P., 1897. History of philosophy of law [Istoriya filosofii prava]. Moscow: Literaturnoe obshchestvo rasprodazhy poleznykh knig.

Petrazhitskii L., 2010. The theory of law and state in connection with the theory of morality [Teoriya prava i gosudarstva v svyazi s teoriei nravstvennosti]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya.

Gredeskul N., 1909. Lectures on general theory of law [Lektsii po obshchei teorii prava]. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya politekhnicheskogo instituta.

Shershenevich G., 1910. General theory of law. First release [Obshchaya teoriya prava. Vypusk pervyi]. Moscow: Izdanie Brat`ev Bashmakovykh.

Korkunov N., 1904. Lectures on general theory of law [Lektsii po obshchei teorii prava]. St. Petersburg: Yuridicheskii kniznyi magazin N. Martynova.

Vinogradov P., 1915. Essays on the theory of law [Ocherki po teorii prava]. Moscow: Postavshchik Dvora Ego Velichestva t-vo skoropechatni A. Levenson.

Rozhdestvenskii A., 1912. Foundations of the general theory of law. Course of lectures given at the Higher Women's Legal Courses in Moscow [Osnovy obshchei teorii prava. Kurs lektsii, chitannykh na Vysshikh Zhenskikh Yuridicheskikh Kursakh v Moskve]. Moscow: Izdatel`stvo V. Spiridonova.

Trubetskoi E., 1917. Lectures on the encyclopedia of law [Lektsii po entsiklopedii prava]. Moscow: Tipografiya A. Mamontova.

Pokrovskii I., 1917. The main problems of civil law [Osnovnye problemy grazhdanskogo prava]. Petrograd: Pravo.

Alekseev N., 1918. Introduction to law studies [Vvedenie v izuchenie prava]. Moscow: Izdanie moskovskoi prosvetitel`skoi komissii.

Alekseev N., 1919. General doctrine of law [Obshchee uchenie o prave]. Simferopol: Tavricheskii universitet.